The peanut butter wars are heating up in 2026. Snickers just launched ads taking shots at Reese's, Reese's fired back, and peanut butter lovers everywhere are picking sides. But here's the real question: why choose?
At StackCart, we stock the full arsenal of peanut butter snacks. Here's your definitive guide to the best PB treats on the market.
š„ The Big Two: Reese's vs. Snickers
Let's address the elephant in the room. These two candy giants have been going at it, and we're here for it.
Team Reese's
The OG peanut butter cup. Reese's has been the gold standard for peanut butter candy since 1928.
- Reese's Peanut Butter Cups ā The classic, available in regular, king size, and minis
- Reese's Pieces ā The E.T. candy, perfect for snacking
- Reese's Sticks ā Wafer meets peanut butter meets chocolate
- Big Cup with Pretzels ā The crunchy twist
- Reese's Puffs Cereal ā Yes, it counts
Team Snickers
Snickers brought peanuts to the candy game, and now they're doubling down on peanut butter.
- Snickers Original ā Peanuts, nougat, caramel, chocolate perfection
- Snickers Peanut Brownie ā The newer, richer option
- Snickers Almond ā For the sophisticated palate
- Snickers Cruncher ā Extra texture, extra good
š„ Beyond the Big Brands: Other PB Champions
The peanut butter snack universe extends far beyond Reese's and Snickers.
Candy & Chocolate
- Butterfinger ā Crispy, flaky, uniquely peanut buttery
- PayDay ā For when you want MORE peanuts
- Take5 ā Peanut butter + pretzels + caramel + peanuts + chocolate
- Nutter Butter Bites ā Bite-sized cookie perfection
- Justin's Peanut Butter Cups ā The organic, slightly fancier option
Cookies & Crackers
- Nutter Butter ā The iconic peanut-shaped cookie
- Girl Scout Do-Si-Dos ā When they're in season, grab them
- Lance Peanut Butter Crackers ā The nostalgic lunch box classic
- Austin Peanut Butter Crackers ā Another solid option
- Ritz with Peanut Butter ā DIY or pre-made, both work
Protein & Health-Focused
- Kind Peanut Butter Bars ā Whole ingredients, great taste
- RXBAR Peanut Butter ā Clean ingredients, serious protein
- Quest Peanut Butter Cups ā Low carb version for the macro counters
- Perfect Bar Peanut Butter ā Refrigerated, protein-packed
š Our Top Picks
If we had to choose (we don't, but hypothetically):
- Best Classic: Reese's Peanut Butter Cups ā Nothing beats the original
- Best Value: Snickers Fun Size Bags ā Perfect for sharing (or not)
- Best for Crunchy Lovers: Take5 ā So much texture in one bar
- Best Healthy Option: Kind Peanut Butter Bar ā Feels like a treat, actually nutritious
- Best Underrated: PayDay ā Criminally underappreciated
š Peanut Butter Snack Pairings
Elevate your PB game with these combinations:
- Reese's + Ghost Energy Drink ā Chocolate peanut butter energy synergy
- Snickers + Cold Brew ā Afternoon pick-me-up combo
- Nutter Butter + Milk ā Classic for a reason
- PB Crackers + Apple Slices ā For when you're feeling healthy-ish
š Find Your Favorites at StackCart
Whether you're Team Reese's, Team Snickers, or Team "Why Not Both," we've got you covered. Stop by our store in Granby, MA or browse online at stack-cart.com.
The peanut butter wars rage on. Pick your side. Or don't. š„
Small Town, Big Savings.