What Is Lucky Ones? Dave Portnoy's Answer to Your Summer Drink Needs
If you've been paying attention to the drinks aisle lately, you've probably noticed a newcomer sitting next to your usual hard seltzers: Lucky Ones. This isn't just another vodka lemonade—it's Dave Portnoy's personal entry into the ready-to-drink game, and it's already turning heads in the beverage world.
Lucky Ones launched with a simple premise: create a premium vodka lemonade that actually tastes like something you'd make at home, not like a science experiment. And here in Massachusetts, where Barstool Sports got its start, there's a certain hometown pride in seeing Portnoy's empire expand from pizza reviews to poolside refreshments.
At StackCart in Granby, MA, we've been stocking Lucky Ones since we got our beer and wine license, and the response has been overwhelmingly positive. But is it actually worth the hype? Let's break it down.
Lucky Ones Flavor Breakdown: Tasting Every Variety
Classic Lemonade
Let's start with the original. The Classic Lemonade is what happens when someone actually puts quality vodka in a canned cocktail. The first thing you notice is that it doesn't taste artificial—there's a genuine citrus brightness that hits your palate, followed by a smooth finish that doesn't burn.
Sweetness Level: Moderate. Not cloying like some competitors.
ABV: 5%
Best For: Poolside sipping, backyard BBQs, or when you want something simple but elevated.
Strawberry Lemonade
The Strawberry Lemonade takes the classic formula and adds real strawberry flavor—not that artificial candy taste you get from cheaper brands. It's fruity without being overwhelming, with the lemon still playing a supporting role.
Sweetness Level: Slightly sweeter than classic, but balanced.
ABV: 5%
Best For: Beach days, summer parties, anyone who usually reaches for rosé.
Peach Lemonade
This might be the sleeper hit of the lineup. Peach lemonade sounds basic, but Lucky Ones nails it. The peach flavor is ripe and natural-tasting, complementing the tartness of the lemon perfectly.
Sweetness Level: Medium-sweet.
ABV: 5%
Best For: Brunch drinks, golf course beverages, impressing guests who are tired of White Claw.
Watermelon Lemonade
Summer in a can. The Watermelon Lemonade delivers exactly what you'd expect—refreshing watermelon notes with that signature lemon tang. It's the kind of drink that disappears quickly on hot days.
Sweetness Level: Medium.
ABV: 5%
Best For: Pool floats, Fourth of July cookouts, whenever the temperature hits 85°.
How Does Lucky Ones Compare to Other Vodka Lemonades?
Let's address the elephant in the room: there are a LOT of vodka lemonades on the market right now. Here's how Lucky Ones stacks up against the competition.
Lucky Ones vs. High Noon
High Noon has been dominating the hard seltzer/vodka space for a while now, and yes, Dave Portnoy has promoted both brands. But they're actually quite different:
- High Noon is more of a vodka soda with fruit essence—lighter, more effervescent, lower calories
- Lucky Ones is a true vodka lemonade—fuller flavor, more of a cocktail feel, slightly sweeter
Winner: Depends on your mood. High Noon for day drinking when you want something light. Lucky Ones for when you want more flavor and don't mind a few extra calories.
Lucky Ones vs. Mike's Hard Lemonade
Mike's Hard Lemonade was the OG of the category, but let's be honest—it's malt-based and tastes like it. Lucky Ones uses actual vodka, which makes a noticeable difference in smoothness and overall quality.
Winner: Lucky Ones, hands down. Mike's has its nostalgia factor, but Lucky Ones is simply a better product.
Lucky Ones vs. Simply Spiked Lemonade
Simply Spiked has the brand recognition from Simply Orange, and their lemonade is decent. But Lucky Ones has a cleaner taste—less syrupy, more refreshing.
Winner: Lucky Ones edges out Simply Spiked for those who prefer a less sweet drink.
The Barstool Connection: Why Massachusetts Loves Lucky Ones
Here's the thing about Lucky Ones that doesn't show up in taste tests: there's a story behind it. Dave Portnoy started Barstool Sports in Milton, Massachusetts, back in 2003. He's a Boston guy through and through, and there's something satisfying about supporting a brand that came from our backyard.
At StackCart, we're all about local connections. We're based in Granby, serving Western Massachusetts, and when we stock Lucky Ones, we're stocking something that has New England roots. It's the same reason we carry local snacks and regional favorites—community matters.
Plus, if you're a Barstool fan (and there are plenty in the Pioneer Valley), drinking Lucky Ones while watching One Bite pizza reviews just hits different.
Best Food Pairings for Lucky Ones Vodka Lemonade
A great drink deserves great snacks. Here's what pairs perfectly with each Lucky Ones flavor:
Classic Lemonade Pairs With:
- Grilled chicken or fish tacos
- Light, salty chips (kettle cooked work great)
- Fresh fruit platters
- Caprese salad
Strawberry Lemonade Pairs With:
- White chocolate
- Vanilla cookies or shortbread
- Strawberry-topped desserts
- Light cheeses like brie or goat cheese
Peach Lemonade Pairs With:
- BBQ pork or pulled pork sandwiches
- Pecan anything
- Honey-glazed ham
- Sweet potato chips
Watermelon Lemonade Pairs With:
- Feta cheese and mint
- Prosciutto
- Cucumber salads
- Light, refreshing appetizers
Stop by StackCart and we'll help you build the perfect drink-and-snack combo for your next gathering.
When to Drink Lucky Ones: The Ideal Occasions
Lucky Ones isn't trying to be an everyday drink—it's positioned as something special. Here's when it really shines:
Pool Days and Beach Trips
The aluminum can is perfect for poolside (no glass allowed most places), and the flavors scream summer. Pack a cooler with ice, throw in a 4-pack of Lucky Ones, and you're set.
Backyard BBQs
When you're grilling and want something more interesting than beer but easier than mixing cocktails, Lucky Ones fills that gap perfectly. It's also a crowd-pleaser—even people who usually stick to wine tend to enjoy it.
Boat Days
Lake Wyola, Quabbin Reservoir, wherever you're floating in Western Mass—Lucky Ones travels well and tastes great on the water.
Golf Course Beverages
At 5% ABV, you can enjoy a couple over 18 holes without losing your swing (too much). The cans fit perfectly in cart cup holders.
Pre-Gaming Before Going Out
When you want something light before heading to the bar, Lucky Ones gets the job done without filling you up like beer would.
Nutritional Information: What's Actually in Lucky Ones?
For those watching their intake, here's the breakdown:
- Calories: Approximately 100-120 per can (varies by flavor)
- Sugar: Around 2-4 grams
- Carbs: 5-7 grams
- ABV: 5%
- Gluten: Gluten-free (made with vodka, not malt)
Compared to a traditional mixed vodka lemonade you'd make at home (which can easily hit 200+ calories with regular lemonade), Lucky Ones is reasonably waistline-friendly.
Where to Buy Lucky Ones in Western Massachusetts
If you're in the Granby, Amherst, or Pioneer Valley area, StackCart is your go-to spot for Lucky Ones. We're located at 77 West State St in Granby, and we keep all four flavors stocked (when supply allows—these do move fast in summer).
You can also check availability online at stack-cart.com or stop by the store to see what's in the cooler today.
The Verdict: Is Lucky Ones Worth It?
Let's cut to the chase: Yes, Lucky Ones is worth trying.
Is it the best vodka lemonade ever made? That's subjective. But it's definitely in the top tier. The quality is there, the flavors are well-executed, and there's something satisfying about the whole Barstool/Boston connection if you're a local.
Who Should Buy Lucky Ones:
- Anyone who likes vodka lemonades but wants something better than the budget options
- Barstool Sports fans (obviously)
- People who are tired of hard seltzers and want more flavor
- Massachusetts residents who want to support a brand with local roots
- Anyone hosting summer parties who wants an easy crowd-pleaser
Who Might Skip It:
- Strict calorie counters who prefer ultra-light seltzers
- People who don't like lemonade-style drinks
- Anyone opposed to the Barstool brand (hey, we get it)
FAQ: Lucky Ones Vodka Lemonade
Is Lucky Ones actually made with vodka?
Yes, Lucky Ones is made with real vodka, not malt liquor like some competitors. This gives it a cleaner, smoother taste.
How many calories are in Lucky Ones?
Approximately 100-120 calories per 12 oz can, depending on the flavor. It's relatively low-calorie compared to traditional cocktails.
Is Lucky Ones gluten-free?
Yes, because it's made with vodka (which is distilled from grains but the distillation process removes gluten), Lucky Ones is considered gluten-free.
Who owns Lucky Ones?
Lucky Ones is Dave Portnoy's vodka lemonade brand. Portnoy is the founder of Barstool Sports, headquartered in Boston.
Where can I buy Lucky Ones in Massachusetts?
Lucky Ones is available at StackCart in Granby, MA, as well as many liquor stores and retailers throughout the state. Availability varies by location.
What's the best Lucky Ones flavor?
This is subjective, but the Classic Lemonade and Peach Lemonade tend to be fan favorites. The Classic is great for purists, while Peach offers something a bit different.
How does Lucky Ones compare to High Noon?
High Noon is more of a vodka soda with fruit essence—lighter and more effervescent. Lucky Ones is a fuller-bodied vodka lemonade with more sweetness and flavor intensity.
Can I buy Lucky Ones online?
Online alcohol purchasing depends on your state's laws. In Massachusetts, check local retailers like StackCart or use delivery services that operate in your area.
Final Thoughts: Summer 2026's Go-To Drink
Lucky Ones has carved out a solid niche in the crowded ready-to-drink market. It's not trying to be everything to everyone—it's a quality vodka lemonade for people who want something that actually tastes good without the hassle of mixing cocktails.
Next time you're in Granby, stop by StackCart and grab a variety pack. Better yet, pair it with some of our snacks for the ultimate summer combo. Your cooler will thank you.
StackCart is located at 77 West State St, Granby, MA. We're your local spot for drinks, snacks, and everything in between. Small town, big savings.